Max Kepler’s signing with the Philadelphia Phillies this offseason came with the expectation of proving his ability against left-handed pitching. However, Kepler has expressed frustration over what he perceives as a lack of opportunity to do so. “I mean, I signed here being told that I was going to be the starting left fielder,” Kepler stated. “The everyday starting left fielder. So, there’s my answer. That’s why I came here.”
Manager Rob Thomson acknowledged Kepler’s situation, stating, “I trust Max. I really do…But I see where the frustration is because these guys want to play — and that’s a good thing.” Thomson admitted he hadn’t spoken to Kepler about his comments before meeting with the media but did talk briefly with him during pregame warmups.
Kepler has started only three out of 24 games against left-handed starters this season, while he has consistently played against right-handers. Despite facing right-handed pitchers 71% of the time this season, three of the first five games were against lefties, in which Kepler started two.
Thomson remarked on players’ rhythm issues due to inconsistent playing time: “I hear the whole rhythm thing…if you think that by having a day off, it’s going to ruin your rhythm, well, it probably will.”
The Phillies seem set on maintaining platoons in several positions despite frustrations from players like Kepler. When asked if there would be changes to this approach, Thomson responded, “Case by case.”
Kepler appears willing to adapt: “If that’s the role I’m given…then transparently, I’ll take it on and hope to make the most of it.” The team may consider acquiring an outfield bat before the July 31 Trade Deadline or promoting internal prospects like Justin Crawford from Triple-A Lehigh Valley.
Regarding potential call-ups for young players like Crawford, Thomson said it depends on team needs and player readiness: “When there’s a need…And [when] he’s ready.”
